Now I'm torn

More photos, showing my old glasses, vs. the two favs in the poll, but with curly hair this time. Does it make a difference when my hair is curly? Or when you see how one is very similar to my old glasses? Do I go with a similar style that I'm used to, or switch it up?

I thought I knew, but now I'm not so sure! Argh!

Left: Pair 1                                         Right: Pair 3

Old frames